Beyond pass or fail: how to grade agent evaluation findings
Grade findings by consequence, reach, reproducibility and control strength, then keep that technical judgement separate from the release decision.
Methods for connecting evaluation cases, measures and thresholds to a decision.
Grade findings by consequence, reach, reproducibility and control strength, then keep that technical judgement separate from the release decision.
Age is only one signal. A dataset becomes stale when its cases, labels or conditions no longer support the decision the evaluation is meant to inform.
A model router is a policy for allocating quality, cost, latency, privacy and failure risk. Evaluate whether each route serves the workflow—not whether routing is fashionable.
A durable agent benchmark needs a declared construct, protected cases, reproducible execution, uncertainty, governance and limits on the claims its scores can support.
Long-running agents accumulate state, dependencies and chances to drift. Evaluation must test checkpoints, recovery, changing conditions and complete outcomes across time.
Start with the choice an owner must make, then derive claims, evidence, cases and measures. The result is smaller, sharper and easier to defend.
A logistics agent earns trust when data becomes late, routes close and plans conflict—not when everything follows the timetable.
Inject realistic faults, verify state and judge the recovery path. A retry that finishes the task can still duplicate work or hide uncertainty.
KEEP EXPLORING
Read the method, assumptions and questions to ask.